Zen Philosophy

I knew a Zen Roshi once, Suzuki Roshi. He was a very calm fellow, easy to be around. He died trying to rescue his daughter who had fallen off a boat. It was tragic. It reminded me of Shunryu Suzuki in Zen Mind, Beginner’s Mind. He talked about how everything is suffering in close-up but that happens in a background of perfect harmony.

ZMBM was my first dharma book and it really spoke to me. I felt as though someone was finally telling the unvarnished truth. By the time, I finished, I was a Buddhist looking for a home. To me, that was the pith of Zen Philosophy: we are perpetually out of balance, but the universe is always in flow.

Tatagathagharba and Emptiness in Zen Philosophy

Buddha-Nature and Tao:

• The idea of Buddha-nature (all beings have the potential for enlightenment) resonated with the Chinese concept of Tao (underlying reality).

2. Sunyata and “Wu”:

• Initially, Sunyata (emptiness) was misinterpreted as the Taoist concept of “wu” (nothingness).

3. The Five Skandhas and Emptiness:

• Yogacara explains emptiness as the way our perception shapes our experience of the world.
• The five skandhas (elements of experience) are not inherently real but arise from our mental processes.

4. Evolution of Understanding:

• Over time, Chinese Buddhists came to understand Sunyata differently:
  • It doesn’t imply nothingness.
  • It refers to the absence of inherent existence in phenomena.

5. Legacy in Zen:

• Zen teachings still reference Buddha-nature but emphasize it as inseparable from Sunyata (emptiness of self and phenomena).

Nondual nature of Relative and Absolute in Zen Philosophy

• Prajnaparamita Sutras and Madhyamaka: These Buddhist texts emphasize the non-duality of form (physical world) and emptiness (ultimate reality). This means ultimate reality isn’t separate; it’s interwoven with the everyday world we experience.
• Emptiness and the Everyday World: This concept aligns with Chinese culture, which values the present world.
• The Question of Duality: While these texts deny a clear separation between suffering (samsara) and enlightenment (nirvana), they don’t fully explain how they connect in our experience.
• Bridging the Gap: Zen Buddhist teachings like the Five Ranks of Tozan, Oxherding Pictures, and Hakuin’s Four Ways of Knowing provide frameworks for understanding the interplay between the absolute (emptiness) and the relative (everyday world).
• Other Buddhist Schools: Madhyamaka’s Two Truths doctrine and Yogacara’s Three Natures and Trikaya doctrines also offer explanations for this relationship.

2 Types of transference – direct and Studied

This passage explores the concept of “mind-to-mind transmission” in Zen, highlighting a potential tension:

Two Modes of Transmission:

• Esoteric Transmission (Mind-to-Mind): This emphasizes direct, teacher-to-student transfer of wisdom, often described metaphorically (flame to candle, vein to vein).
• Exoteric Transmission (Self-Discovery): This focuses on personal exploration and realization of one’s true nature, symbolized by finding a light or seeing oneself in a mirror.

Zen Philosophy and the Balancing Act:

• Zen prioritizes both aspects:
  • Maintaining the lineage and proper Dharma transmission through teachers.
  • Emphasizing individual awakening and “seeing into one’s nature.”

Importance of Teachers:

• A Zen master, Torei Enji, emphasizes the crucial role of teachers in guiding students towards enlightenment, even for those who seem naturally gifted.

Independent Awakening:

• Despite the emphasis on teachers, there are known cases of Zen masters (like Nonin, Jinul, and Suzuki Shosan) who attained enlightenment on their own, demonstrating the potential for independent realization.

Satori and graduated path in Zen Philosophy

Two Main Views:

• Sudden Enlightenment: Insight into one’s true nature happens instantly, followed by no further confusion.
• Gradual Enlightenment: An initial awakening is followed by a period of practice to refine understanding and achieve full Buddhahood.

Historical Context:

• Early Chinese Chan Buddhism acknowledged both sudden and gradual aspects of enlightenment.
• Shenhui (8th century) emphasized sudden enlightenment and downplayed the gradual approach.

Reconciliation and Modern Views:

• The Platform Sutra and later teachers like Zongmi and Chinul reconciled the views, seeing sudden awakening as the beginning, followed by gradual cultivation.
• Modern schools like Sanbo Kyodan see initial enlightenment as the start of the journey.

Gradual Cultivation Practices:

• These practices help deepen the initial awakening and lead to full enlightenment. Examples include:
  • The Five Ranks of Enlightenment by Tozan
  • The Ten Ox-Herding Pictures
  • The Three Mysterious Gates of Linji
  • The Four Ways of Knowing of Hakuin

Impact of Sutras:

• The emphasis on sudden enlightenment aligns with the Diamond Sutra’s focus on “all or nothing” realization of emptiness.
• The Lankavatara Sutra, with its gradual approach to purifying the mind, reflects a different perspective.

Debates and Solutions:

• The sudden vs. gradual debate created its own arguments and divisions within Zen.
• Some, like Zongmi, devised new classifications to elevate the importance of Chan teachings.

Summary of Zen Philosophy and Influences

Key Points:

• Zen philosophy and the Moon Analogy:
  • Zen teachings are like a finger pointing at the moon, guiding you towards awakening (realizing the interconnectedness of everything). However, the teachings themselves are not the awakening itself.
• Mahayana Buddhist Roots: Despite claims of being separate from scriptures, Zen has a strong foundation in Mahayana Buddhist ideas.
• Key Mahayana Influences:
  • The path of the Bodhisattva (enlightened being who helps others)
  • Madhyamaka philosophy (emptiness)
  • Yogacara philosophy (consciousness-only)
  • Prajñaparamita teachings (perfection of wisdom)
  • Laṅkāvatāra Sūtra (influential Mahayana text)
  • Buddha-nature texts (idea that all beings have the potential for Buddhahood)
• Additional Influences:
  • Huayan school philosophy (interpenetration of phenomena)
• Central Doctrines:
  • Buddha-nature: the idea that the awakened mind of a Buddha is inherent in all beings.
  • Subitism: the concept of sudden enlightenment, as opposed to gradual practice.
• Impact of Subitism:
  • Emphasis on direct insight and expression of Buddha-nature.
  • Focus on “one moment” enlightenment experiences.
• Paradoxical Nature of Zen Texts:
  • They point directly to awakening but don’t describe specific meditation practices.
  • They use koans (paradoxical riddles) to challenge logic and provoke intuitive understanding.

Key Points of Zen Philosophy

Central Entity: Zen Philosophy (Zen Buddhism)

Category: School of Mahayana Buddhism

Origin:

• Developed in China during the Tang dynasty (618-907 CE)
• Evolved from the Chan school (Chánzong)

Core Tenets:

• Meditation (zazen): Emphasizes breath awareness and letting go of distractions.
• Direct Insight (kensho): Gaining intuitive understanding of one’s true nature as Buddha-mind.
• Living in the Present Moment: Focus on the present, free from attachments to past or future.
• Simplicity (wabi-sabi): Finding beauty in imperfection and appreciating life’s simple joys.
• Benefitting Others: Expressing personal enlightenment through actions that help others.

Practices:

• Zazen: Seated meditation practice
• Koans (Rinzai school): Paradoxical riddles used to challenge logical thinking and awaken intuition.
• Shikantaza (Soto school): Just sitting meditation focusing on maintaining a relaxed posture and following the breath.

Sub-schools (Japan):

• Rinzai: Emphasizes koan study and sudden enlightenment experiences.
• Soto: Emphasizes shikantaza meditation and a gradual path to enlightenment.

Influences:

• Mahayana Buddhist Traditions:
  • Yogachara
  • Tathāgatagarbha sutras
  • Laṅkāvatāra Sūtra
  • Huayan school
  • Prajñāpāramitā literature
  • Madhyamaka thought
• Taoist Philosophy: Particularly Neo-Daoism

Spread:

• From China to:
  • Vietnam (becoming Thiền)
  • Korea (becoming Seon)
  • Japan (becoming Zen)

Impact:

• Profoundly influenced cultures of Vietnam, Korea, and Japan
• Continues to attract practitioners worldwide seeking inner peace and mindfulness

Related Concepts:

• Mahayana Buddhism
• Meditation
• Enlightenment
• Buddha-nature
• Mindfulness
• Simplicity
• Wabi-sabi
• Koans
• Japanese Zen (unique characteristics)

Additional Notes:

• Zen emphasizes personal experience and de-emphasizes knowledge gained solely from scriptures.
• A teacher plays a crucial role in guiding students on their Zen path.
• Modern Western Zen adapts traditional teachings to contemporary culture.

Subitism

Subitism is the doctrine of Sudden Enlightenment.

Meaning:

• The term subitism comes from the idea that enlightenment (awakening to one’s true nature) can occur suddenly or all at once, rather than through a gradual process of practice and learning.
• It’s often contrasted with gradualism, the more common approach in Buddhism that emphasizes a step-by-step path to enlightenment.

Connection to Zen Philosophy:

• Subitism is a defining characteristic of Zen, particularly the Rinzai school which heavily utilizes koans (paradoxical riddles) to challenge logic and provoke sudden intuitive understanding.
• The idea is that encountering a koan can be the catalyst for a sudden breakthrough in awareness, leading to enlightenment.

Criticisms:

• Some argue that subitism downplays the importance of dedicated practice and discipline on the path to enlightenment.
• The emphasis on suddenness can be discouraging for practitioners who don’t experience immediate results.

Understanding Subitism:

• It’s important to see subitism not as a guarantee of instant enlightenment, but rather as a possibility.
• The suddenness refers to a shift in perspective, not necessarily the complete realization of enlightenment.
• Consistent practice, including meditation, reflection, and ethical living, is still crucial in Zen, even with the emphasis on subitism.

Related Concepts:

• Kensho: The experience of seeing one’s true nature, often described as a sudden insight.
• Koans: Paradoxical riddles used to challenge logical thinking and provoke intuitive understanding. Not as emphasized in Zen Philosophy as some believe.
• Zazen: Seated meditation practice, essential for cultivating focus and mindfulness.

Series Navigation

<< Zen Buddhism – What is Zen?Zazen >>